
We are all responsible for the horse in the skip bin
Opinion + AnalysisSociety + Culture
BY Daniel Finlay 20 NOV 2026
On Monday 16 November, a racehorse was found dumped in a landfill skip bin. The horse was a five-year-old named So You Are who finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup just a few weeks prior and was euthanised by a vet two days before being found after unresolvable medical complications.
To me, this news is as horrifying as it is unsurprising. But most frustrating of all is some of the media coverage of the situation.
When certain public kinds of animal abuse happen, people like to treat them as anomalies. We are shocked, appalled, outraged, that such a corruption of our humanity could occur. We hear from people inside and outside industry lamenting the unfair and undignified treatment of these poor souls and calling for the head of the guilty.
In this case, the horse’s trainer was quick to voice his love and grief at the disrespect of the burial. “He was a much-loved horse, and he deserved to be treated with dignity and respect after his death.” Much of the public shares this disappointment about the treatment of the body after death.
The problem with this is that it is not an anomaly; it is an inevitable outcome of an unethical system of exploitation masquerading as sport, entertainment and profit.
From my perspective, the way that So You Are’s body was treated matters mostly as a reflection of industry and societal attitudes towards animals, and less so as the one-off barbarity that it’s portrayed as in headlines. We should be much less concerned about the optics of a horse in landfill and much more concerned about how we arrived at an environment that allowed it to happen – an environment where an understandably upset trainer can at the same time be oblivious to his role in a system of animal abuse.
A horse does not care how his body is treated after his death, but he did care how he lived and died.
Some articles have attempted to bring nuance to the table, but most seem much more concerned about the effects of the body in the bin rather than the bigger picture. Cathrynne Henshall writes for the ABC: “The distress belongs to the people who cared for him, and the real risk is to the animals that might eat from the carcass.” She then concludes: “If this case makes us care more about horses, that attention belongs with the living: how they are housed, trained, raced and retired, and whether their deaths are timely and humane.”
These aren’t questions with unknown answers that are just up for the reader’s interpretation. There are plenty of watchdogs and whistleblowers within the racing industry that collect information about the mistreatment of horses. But let’s focus on the main issue. Horse racing in Australia between 2024-2025 involved 35,625 horses and in that time 175 of them were killed – an average of one horse every two days. That’s a death rate of 1 in 200. For comparison, boxing is one of the deadliest sports for humans averaging 13 deaths per year or a death rate of 1 in 7,600. Do we truly think that horses deserve, through no choice of their own, to be subjected to almost 40 times more danger than we’re willing to subject ourselves to?
These horses are not dying of old age. Most racehorses are just four or five years old when they are killed and they are dying of exhaustion, heart attacks, and most commonly limb injuries. Limb injuries that are often not life-threatening, but profit-threatening. Racehorses who can no longer race are worthless in an industry that values a life by how much money it can make you.
It’s easy to be momentarily appalled by the very public disregard of life that we see in this news story. It is much harder to challenge our acceptance of the industry and culture that causes it.
If we think that So You Are deserved a better death, we should also think he, and all horses like him, deserved a better life. A life free of racing.

BY Daniel Finlay
Daniel is a philosopher, writer and editor. He works at The Ethics Centre as Youth Engagement Coordinator, supporting and developing the futures of young Australians through exposure to ethics.
Ethics in your inbox.
Get the latest inspiration, intelligence, events & more.
By signing up you agree to our privacy policy
You might be interested in…
Opinion + Analysis
Relationships, Society + Culture
But how do you know? Hijack and the ethics of risk
Opinion + Analysis
Society + Culture
Read before you think: 10 dangerous books for FODI22
Opinion + Analysis
Relationships, Society + Culture
Violence and technology: a shared fate
Opinion + Analysis
Society + Culture